Friday, October 21, 2016

LET THE BOYS CRY TOO.


I am delighted to have touched a lot of people, who read my last blog, "A Loud and Clear Voice." I received a lot of comments and suggestions and I am very thankful for the responses that I received. I am sure my words  did not hurt, they only made my reader sit up and take stock of the situation around him/her. If each one of us becomes aware and helps improve the situation, then the next generation will have every reason to be thankful to us for having left the world a better place.

All of us take so many things for granted, that a lot of subtle hurts, insults, humiliations become a part of our life. Inadvertently a lot of patterns get set in our everyday life that majority of us do not even feel the pinch that we are either causing or receiving.

About forty years ago, I was posted as a Junior Officer in the bank in Chandigarh. A male officer and I were posted as Field officers and sat on the first floor of the huge sprawling building. We both had desks next to each other. On a particularly tiring day both of us  were looking forward to going home and waiting for the clock to tell us that it was time to go home when my colleague said,
"Oh I am so tired today. I will go home and rest after a good cup of tea. I am sure my wife will have made some pakodas(vegetable fritters) too."
A light bulb suddenly switched on in my head and I discovered how everything was so different for him and me.  I too would go home, prepare tea for my parents in law, my husband and myself, then make sure that my children drank their milk without fuss and then went out to play in the park infront of my house. After that I would prepare the dinner for everyone, lay the table, pick up after everyone,  tidy up the kitchen and only then catch up on that much needed rest.

Although much water has flown down the Ganges in the last forty years, and a lot of attitudes have since changed, yet even today I  see a number of girls leaving their jobs to bring up their children. It does make me wonder why it is always a woman who takes a break to look after her children, why does a man never take on the role of a stay at home dad? I have seen very qualified girls from the best Institutes taking a back seat in life.  The mind set that women are softer, and more caring, needs to be examined de novo. According to me soft touch, mother's instinct, nurturing capabilities of women are much hyped abilities. Can a man not be caring and soft? Are they really devoid of feelings or are they just encouraged to maintain a macho image? I have seen more men cry in movies then women. Perhaps in the darkened movie theatre they are able to vent out their pent up emotions easily. Why are we so unfair to men? Why do we not allow them to express their emotions?

I believe that a man can be as kind, considerate and caring of his children if he is given the responsibility.  The fact remains that women's position is always secondary in our society and a movie like "Ki and Ka" which has role reversal as its theme is seen with a lot of trepidation. Here I can cite my own example. When my children were small and would wake up at night, it was always my husband who would attend to them and never wake me up.

In London where my daughter lives, I used to go to pick up my grand daughter from school on some days and saw a few men also come to pick up their children. The mothers sometimes would get together for coffee and one of the fathers would always join in at the mother's coffee do. He was a stay at home dad who looked after his two children while his wife pursued her career full time. In western societies I have seen very close cooperation and sharing of all domestic chores as there is no demarcation of your task and my task.  It is always common work which is performed by either spouse on different days. I do fervently hope that this trend catches on here too and we have more men coming up to take on the role of a caring parent along with sharing of domestic work.


 A lot of people have said that women are the worst enemies of their own kind. I totally agree with them.  It is a mother who is the first teacher of her children.
It is a mother who tells her little son when he cries,
"Don't be a sissy. Why are you crying like a girl?"
"Are you a girl? Why are you crying?"
"You are a boy, boys don't cry. Boys are strong."

A little girl is never told to stop crying with any analogy.

Why on earth can a boy not cry? Why do we have these set patterns? What is wrong in crying?
Boys as well as girls feel hurt, sad, pained, insulted and humiliated.  Why should the reactions not be the same for boys and girls? Why should the boys control their tears and hide their feelings? Teach both boys and girls to control their tears if at all you think that tears must be controlled.  Personally I believe that one need not control tears, let them be shed if it relieves you of some hurt and pain.
Is it not time that mothers and fathers thought about what they are saying to their children?
This is how the seeds of inequality get sown in the minds of the little children who are exposed to this verbal abuse. Yes, I have used the word "abuse" because this is how we are instilling some set patterns of inequality in the minds of very unbiased young people. 

A very topical event about inequality right now is the Karwa Chouth fast that just got over.  This is a women oriented fast and is often a mother in law enforced fast. Thanks to movies and TV serials more and more women from all over the country have become aware of this basically North Indian festival and this year I saw a number of young ladies from Bengal and Maharashtra observe this fast. This is a fast that women keep for the longevity of their husband.

The latest generation  of girls  in big cities, I believe is highly educated, emancipated and evolved. They pursue complex careers, live independently and yet practice this fast. Does anyone actually believe that keeping this fast helps increase longevity of their husband? Really?

Some of the girls I spoke with are eternal romantics, who see something beautiful and filmy about being that loving and caring devoted wife who wants to keep a fast and adorn lovely clothes and jewellery to remain in touch with her Indian traditions by keeping a fast in a fast changing modern world. They perhaps want to simply  clutch on to some colourful romantic moments with old world charms.

I say keep the romance alive but please do not believe that your fast will actually increase the life span of your husband. I personally believe that some traditions and rituals need to be relegated as they actually demean the status of women, and it is in the interest of women to ensure that we create a free and fair world for the next generation of girls who are going to grow up to be women of the future in an equal and fair world unburdened with the task of ensuring the longevity of her husband, where no one takes on anything for ensuring her longevity.


Women  of all strata and from every set up, be it rural, urban or metropolitan, are exceptionally gifted people. They are born managers and their skills need to be studied and harnessed. Women can balance out and manage their time without any  external inputs. They are exceptionally capable as at any given time  they can cook, watch over the home work of the child, provide tea to her husband, listen to the school stories of the children with patience and also listen to the woes of the husband who just wants a sounding board who will give him no advice. No advice? True, no advice, as a wife is seldom treated as an intellectual who can give correct advice. There are exceptions of course.

This is a very stray example but I have heard this many times. If a wife says,"Lets go see X movie, I have heard it is very good."
The husband disregards it until one fine day he comes back from work and says,"Get ready quickly, we are going to see X movie, my friend XYZ has said that this movie is very good."

Well men and women who are emancipated and care, please do instil a sense of equality in all the children in your house.
Let boys and girls be equal. Let them know that they are equal. Teach them the same standards, arts and crafts, cooking and cleaning. Teach them that they are caring and nurturing people. They are all soft and kind. If a girl loves rough sports encourage her and if a boy loves cooking please encourage him. If a boy loves to play with dolls so be it, if a girl doesn't want to play with dolls let her be. Let there be no macho image and no fair and lovely. Let them grow up in a beautiful world which has a place for everyone. Let them claim their own space as they wish to.



















5 comments:

Ranjana Bharij said...

While I fully agree with what you state here Varsha, I am amused as I had also penned some similar thoughts almost five years ago in my blog
http://banjaran1949.blogspot.in/2011/10/fasting-on-karwa-chauth-as-i-look-at-it.html
It would be interesting to read them too while we are on the subject.

Varsha Uke Nagpal said...

Deep Singh said,"That's a very refreshing read, Varsha. Primarily because it speaks of a person who's thinking for herself and even more importantly encouraging those around her to live their lives by their own lights rather than being trapped unthinkingly into just going through life on terms dictated by all and sundry."

Varsha Uke Nagpal said...

Man Singh said,"You write so beautifully that it makes ripples on my thinking process.However, none except Madam Ranjana Bharij has come forward to join/contradict such an important myth ' boys do not cry'.You courageously make your point- Let the boys cry too knowing well that the gender equality still a far cry in Indian patriarchal social system."

Meena Mishra said...

Varsha ,
This is Meena Mishra from Mumbai. I fully agree with you and your thoughts dear. I don't know what is the scenario elsewhere but here in schools we have something called LSE ( Life Skill Education).The boys are oriented that it's ok to cry . Actually they are taught that it's okay to cry even in a public place.Just express yourself.
Rest of the things like keeping fast and all, actually girls take it more in copying others.
Good read dear.

Varsha Uke Nagpal said...

Meena Mishra, Thank you very much for your comments. It is very gratifying to know that boys are actually told that they can cry. It is the need of the times to let boys also feel human with human feelings.

Related Posts with Thumbnails